Welcome to the Anti-Debt Agenda

The average American works ten years of their life just to pay interest.

Americans are routinely forced into debt for education and medical care – which are paid for by taxes  in many other nations. Credit cards are a very poor substitute for union cards.

Norwegians, Danes, Czechs,  Germans, or Swedes do not need to borrow for college – it is free. The Germans and Dutch do not need to borrow for health care – everyone is insured, and deductibles cannot exceed a few hundred dollars.

As Astra Taylor says: “Working people in America are robbed twice. You’re underpaid at the job, and then you’re charged interest because  you need student loans to get an education, and then you’re going into debt for medical care, and you may need other loans just to pay rent or put food on the table.”

Student debt, medical debt, and carceral debts (for bail, probation, and court costs)  should not exist at all.  These debts are the foundation of what Tressie McMillan Cottom calls “negative social insurance…..  it doesn’t actually make us more secure. It only makes our collective insecurity more profitable.” 

Our blog will not focus on consumer debts for  homes, new cars or flat-screen TV’s. These debts may just reflect bad personal decisions. The existing bankruptcy laws are probably adequate remedies.

What we will oppose are the debts that arise from the lack of social insurance. The creditors here are clearly not entitled to full repayment with interest. We must expand the  category of forgivable debts. 

As Robert Meister asks regarding student debt: “Why not raise taxes and provide higher education as a publicly funded good that does not depend upon individual access to private credit markets?

“If you add up the lifetime debt service that former students will pay on $1 trillion, over and above the principal they borrow, you could run a very good public university system for what we are paying capital markets to fund an ever-worsening one.”

This blog will discuss and reprint articles on the size of the problem, along with proposed solutions.

Always feel free to provide comments, criticisms, and suggestions.


Recent Blog Posts

  • Bob Hertz’s Music Festival: Twenty Three of My Favorites

    MOVIE SCORES….  1. Cavatina….score of The Deer Hunter  I remember sitting in the back row of a small movie house at the end of Deer Hunter, and crying my eyes out at this piece. It somehow evokes all the aspirations of each main character in the movie – and the terrible disappointments for each and every one of them. There were so many tragedies in the late 1960’s and 1970’s, we forget them so easily. 2. The Big Combo, title sequence by David Raskin For me this is a marvelous, unknown musical achievement…incredibly evocative. 3. Godfather theme, orchestral suite I…

  • Coinsurance  – Another Rip-off in Health Care

    Let’s say that a health policy is advertised as follows:  Fast forward — you have a serious illness, and wind up with a $40,000 hospital bill. You pay the first $7,000, which is your deductible…. then you pay coinsurance –   20% of the remaining $33,000, or $6,600….. finally, the insurer pays the remainder, which in this case is just $26,400. I call this a $13,600 effective deductible for hospital stays.   The insurance company is doing fine….after all, they only had to pay out $26,400 on a $40,000 claim. The insured has paid $13,600 – and remember, that’s after forking…

  • The Trump administration Will Be Tough on Student Loans

    Here’s how…. 1. Opposition to Broad Forgiveness: The administration has stated that “Taxpayers—not students and parents—must not be forced to repay student loans that do not belong to them.”   This administration is broadly opposed to presidential-level debt cancellation plans. 2. Ending Repayment Plans: The administration is moving to terminate certain existing income-driven repayment (IDR) plans, such as the SAVE plans. The financial pain to borrowers will be  massive. 3. Changes to PSLF: The administration  will propose revisions to the Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) program, which critics argue is intended to restrict eligibility.  4. Resumption of Involuntary Collections: The Department…

  • Medical Debt Forgiveness is Beautiful – But Not a Cure-All 

    RIP Medical Debt has become prominent in the fight against health care debt burdens. Once the funders purchase these debts, their next step is always to cancel them. This should be a blessed event for the families who are currently in debt. However —   are these efforts delivering on their promise? Not completely, according to the largest study to date of medical debt relief programs.   Neale Mahoney at Stanford could find no evidence that buying and then forgiving medical debts improved the average beneficiaries’ finances, access to credit, or their physical or mental health.  The beneficiaries were even less likely to…

  • Predatory PayDay Loans Are Hard to Stop

    There are 20 million payday and car title loans made each year…….and their  “track record”  is extremely ugly. Given this hideous record of undesired, undeniable consequences, numerous cities and states have tried to regulate the interest rates on these loans. In the face of such regulation, what did the payday loan industry do?   In some cases,  they secretly installed their loan business on Indian reservations, and went on doing business as usual under the name of the tribe. If anyone complained, the  crafty lenders said that their  practices were covered by tribal law.                      Each loan agreement explicitly stated (falsely) that…

  • Can You Declare Bankruptcy From Student Loans?

    Student loan debtors are very nervous about their new higher loan payments. If they cannot get “income-based repayment” — for whatever reason– the new payments may be economically back-breaking. I have had borrowers ask me if they could declare bankruptcy. Until a couple of years ago, my answer was that they would probably fail. In many cases, the Government would actually send in its own attorneys right away to challenge you. However, there has been a small improvement.  Courts are now open to consider three situations that could produce a successful student loan bankruptcy. This is called the Brunner test….and …

  • Payday Loans Can Be Made By Non-Profits

    Payday loans nationwide are responsible for a large percentage of the really awful, disastrous, family-killing debts that trap low-income Americans.  Payday lenders will gladly tell you about the problems they face, and the costs they have to cover. These loans are massively profitable, nonetheless, for everyone from multinationals to Indian tribes.  Lenders blame their  high costs on the fact that they lend without any credit check on the buyer. Even if they are scoundrels, this is a legitimate problem. Every year there are a small number of non-profits who try to make payday loans at modest interest rates. These good-hearted…

  • Medical Debts Will Increase Under Republicans

    Republicans generally don’t care about medical debt. They consider it their primary mission to lower federal spending. They count on Medicaid recipients being a pretty passive bunch — many do not vote at all, much less vote about health care programs. The Republican One Big Beautiful Bill Act would slash $1.1 trillion from Medicaid, the ACA, and other health care programs over 10 years.  The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimates that 14.2 million people will lose their coverage due to those cuts. That number includes 6.5 million losing Medicaid, and 7.7 million losing ACA marketplace coverage.  Families will lose…

  • The Politics Of Student Loan Forgiveness

    The issue of student loan forgiveness is really the province of the Democratic Party. An astonishing percentage of Republicans (at least astonishing to me) take the attitude of “You made your bed, now lie in it.” Republicans argue that taxpayers would bear the cost of defaults on federal loans. They also argue that it is unfair to those who have already struggled to repay their loans. The “burden on taxpayers” is their weakest point, given the stupendous deficit spending of both Trump administrations. If $50 billion or even $150 billion of student debt goes unpaid, this is small potatoes in the overall Republican…

  • Book Review…..Debt’s Grip

    This new book looks like a great one ……. Debt’s Grip: Risk and Consumer Bankruptcy by Pamela Foohey, Robert M. Lawless, and Deborah Thorne Debt’s Grip uses eleven years of court records and surveys to describe what it means to live in financial precarity in the United States. Bankruptcy filers describe the privations and struggles they suffered. It documents the increasingly lengthy period of time people sit in the financial “sweatbox” before filing bankruptcy.  Several chapters are built around types of debts– home and car debts, medical debts, and credit card and other unsecured debts. An additional chapter discusses how the bankruptcy system both…

  • Uncle Sam – The King Of Debtors

    This blog has been active since 2022, and has covered many aspects of unjust personal debt, such as prisoners owing debt for child support, or veterans owing money for medical care actually received at the VA. My focus has always been on individual debt. I have not addressed the larger problem of public debt. Now it’s time to do that……. You don’t get any larger than the U.S.  national debt — $36 trillion, and growing by $1 trillion every 3-4 months. When the national debt is this large, there is frankly no way to pay it off.  Moreover,  if interest…

  • Chris Hedges On Debt And Exploitation

    Chris Hedges – a former minister and foreign correspondent — has described himself as a socialist and  anarchist. His interviews and blog posts are always stimulating.  He points out: “Workers who are unable to meet their debts are far more likely to remain submissive and compliant. Debt peonage has always been a form of political control: 1. Native Americans, who  were forced by the U.S. government onto tribal agencies, were required to buy their goods on credit at the agency stores.  2. Coal miners in southern West Virginia and Kentucky were paid in scrip by the coal companies — and kept in perpetual…

  • Debt Consolidation Traps

    People in debt are easily tempted by offers to “pay off your high-interest credit card with a new, lower-interest loan.” However, debt consolidation is extremely vulnerable to scammers. Here are nine ways to tell if the offer is a scam: 1. The agency asks for an upfront payment A true financial counseling firm will never ask you for an upfront fee before they review your case. 2. They pressure you to act fast They know how to make you feel flustered enough to give them money without thinking it through. 3. The company contacts you first with an unsolicited offer Scammers may…

  • Challenge That Debt!

    Chrystin Ondersma is a law professor at Rutgers Law School, and an internationally recognized expert in bankruptcy and household debt.  Here are some highlights from her latest book,  Dignity Not Debt. “Anyone who has debt and feels ashamed and alone must understand that it’s not their fault—our whole system is designed to force you to rely on debt, even when it’s obvious you won’t be able to repay it.”  .”The most striking thing in  my debt research is the degree to which Black Americans have been excluded from the opportunity to build wealth in this country.   Black households are much less…

  • Trump Attacks CFPB To Pay Off Campaign Donors

    Trump’s offensive against the Consumer Finance Protective Bureau (CFPB) is not really about libertarian small-government. Nor is it really aimed at cutting back excessive federal spending.  The agency’s cost– which is only $750 million per year- does not have a meaningful impact on the federal budget. The closing is mainly about large financial favors for Trump donors. – The agency dropped its case against Capital One, after accusing the bank of illegally cheating customers out of more than $2 billion in interest payments. – – It also dismissed a case against the student loan servicer Pennsylvania Higher Education Assistance Agency (PHEAA), accused…

  • Anti-Debt Heroes: Marshall Allen, Journalist

    Marshall Allen, a ProPublica investigative reporter who fought for the rights of patients facing unfair medical bills, died last May at age 52 from a heart attack. Allen approached his stories with the moral conviction that doctors, hospitals, drugmakers  and insurers could be  more transparent and humane.  He first showed how a hospital system refused to cover the care of an employee’s premature baby, leaving her with a bill for $898,984.57.  Within days of Allen calling the system’s media representative, the hospital promised to cover the bill. “He would be our tour guide to things that were incredibly enraging,” said Tracy…

  • Eight Reforms To Wipe Out Billions In Medical Debts

    Reform #1. Resolve or Dismiss all medical debt lawsuits initiated by hospitals or collection agencies Medical debt — unlike home mortgages, student loans, and auto loans — is almost never truly voluntary.  People who seek medical care are hurting; they come to the hospital on the worst days of their lives. It is immoral to squeeze them as though they just bought an overpriced wide-screen TV.   People who need health care are suffering. When someone is suffering, to compound their suffering by demanding payment feels immoral.  The presence of pain and chronic illness — and the threat of disability or…

  • Coerced Debt – A Family Backwater

    Coerced debt is typically a form of family exploitation. It commonly begins with using a partner’s credit without their knowledge.    One partner might buy items on Amazon.com using their partner’s credit card information stored in the computer. Or, someone might use a partner’s social security number and other personal information to take out a loan. This easily graduates to the threat of harm to a partner in taking on debt–with the spoken or unspoken threat that if they don’t go along, they’ll be sorry.   Eventually, low-income spouses and girlfriends may feel compelled to take out bail bonds for jailed partners. …

  • Debt Traps For Employees

    In recent years, there has been a widespread imposition of “stay-or-pay” contracts. These agreements force workers to compensate employers if they leave their job before a set time period. The contracts are called  “TRAPS” –  a Training Repayment Agreement Provision.  Employers could legally require workers to pay “liquidated damages” for on-the-job training or use of equipment.  Some of the TRAPS demanded unspecified damages for the cost of recruiting a replacement or for the “lost profits” from a worker’s departure. The debt could easily amount to over $10,000. Employers could also demand that departing employees pay them for not providing a…

  • ANTI DEBT HEROES #5 and #6

    Astra Taylor and Hannah Appel Astra Taylor is a filmmaker, writer, and political organizer. She often appears on Democracy Now and The Laura Flanders Show. Hannah Appel is co-founder of the Debt Collective and a professor of anthropology at UCLA. She is also a director of the Institute on Inequality and Democracy. Their joint article in the recent Non-Profit Quarterly is entitled “They Need Us More Than We Need Them – The Power of Debtor Organizing.” They argue as follows: Starting in the 1970s, the United States moved from a tax-funded welfare state (albeit one that primarily benefited white men…